During what appears to be the 1960s, Wanda and Vision begin to hear strange noises outside their house. The next day, they prepare their magician act for a neighborhood talent show. Wanda and Agnes then spend the day with Dottie and a group of women from the neighborhood while Vision attends a neighborhood watch meeting uninvited.
Wanda befriends another neighbor, Geraldine, and begins to notice other strange things, such as a voice on the radio that seems to be speaking to her. Vision becomes friendly with the local men at the neighborhood watch meeting, and they give him some Big Red gum. When Vision arrives at the talent show, he appears to be intoxicated and reveals his abilities to the neighborhood. Wanda uses her own abilities to make Vision look like he is doing simple magic tricks.
Afterward, Wanda removes the gum from Vision’s gears. Their performance is well received, and they return home happy, wherein they discover that Wanda is now pregnant. Suddenly, they see a strange beekeeper emerging from a manhole on their street. Wanda panics, and their reality resets to before the figure appeared. The setting then changes to the 1970s as everything becomes colorful, and a voice asks Wanda who is controlling her.